More Instant Cash Loans or Better Ones? Why South Africa Needs to Focus on Borrowers, Not Just Lenders
Instant Loans SA (ILSA) director believes South Africa’s short-term lending sector, especially the market for instant cash loans, should be improved with greater transparency, competition and choice alongside more access.
A recent statement by Brett van Aswegen, CEO of Wonga South Africa, has prompted a fresh look at the regulations governing the sector. He argues that these regulations, largely unchanged for over a decade, are limiting access to responsible short-term lending for lower-income consumers.
Van Aswegen states that compliance costs, inflation and the rising cost of doing business have not been factored into the regulated lending fees, which have remained unchanged since 2015. This has led to some registered lenders turning away consumers, and possibly some consumers turning to informal lending.
This is an important point, especially as so many South Africans rely on short-term lending.
However, Sean McCullough, founder of the loan comparison service Instant Loans SA, believes the conversation needs to extend beyond simply making more instant cash loans available.
“There’s an important distinction between giving someone access to a loan and helping them find a loan that actually represents good value. Increasing approval rates might be good news for lenders, but it doesn’t automatically mean consumers are getting a better deal.”
Are High Rates of Loan Rejections a Problem?
The National Credit Regulator revealed that 67% of credit applications were rejected in the second quarter of 2025. This demonstrates that many South Africans are having trouble accessing credit.
Recent analysis of NCR data also shows that in the first quarter of 2026 there were about 20.4 million credit applications, and more than 60% were rejected.
However, high rates of loan rejection are not necessarily a problem.
Responsible lenders are required to determine whether a consumer can afford to repay the loan, even when the consumer is hoping for an immediate payout. Refusing a loan to a consumer who is already in deep credit trouble may help prevent them from getting into even deeper trouble.
McCullough believes this point needs to be made.
“A rejected application can be frustrating, especially when someone needs money urgently. But approving a loan that a customer cannot realistically repay isn’t doing them a favour. The challenge is helping people who genuinely can afford credit find suitable lending options without encouraging those who can’t afford it to take on more debt.”
For loan comparison services, this poses an important question. Should success be measured by increasing the number of instant cash loans approved, or by better matching consumers with the most suitable loans?
Are Higher Lending Fees Beneficial to Consumers?
Wonga has proposed changes to the regulated lending fees to account for compliance costs and inflation. The company believes such a change would increase the level of lending available and widen access to formal lending for consumers currently considered commercially unviable.
There is merit in revisiting regulated lending fees that have remained unchanged for over a decade.
However, increasing the regulated lending fees does not automatically mean that consumers will benefit.
Some lenders may be more willing to provide loans to consumers not previously considered viable. Other lenders may simply increase revenue from consumers who already qualify.
Consumers who are struggling with affordability may find that higher fees make repaying an instant cash loan even more difficult.
“If regulations change to allow lenders to charge more, consumers need stronger reasons and better tools to compare their options. Otherwise, we risk creating a market where loans become more accessible but also more expensive, without necessarily improving people’s financial wellbeing.”
In this situation, competition among lenders becomes important.
The Importance of Comparing Instant Cash Loans
Many South Africans are turning to instant cash loans in response to immediate cash needs, such as an unexpected cost at home, an urgent repair or a temporary shortfall before payday.
In these situations, the promise of an immediate payout can be tempting, and consumers may be inclined to choose the first available loan.
However, the advertised interest rate on a loan may not reflect its total cost, which also depends on initiation fees, service charges and the repayment period.
A consumer focusing only on an immediate payout may not account for the total cost of the loan.
Instant Loans SA is a comparison and loan-matching service, not a lending institution. It connects consumers with regulated lenders participating in the service.
McCullough believes that providing consumers with information about available loans is an important part of increasing financial inclusion.
“Consumers should never feel that the first lender willing to approve them is automatically their best option. Even when someone needs money quickly, understanding the fees, repayment terms and total cost of borrowing can make a meaningful difference.”
Consumers may find suitable providers of instant cash loans by using a comparison service. However, being matched with a lender should not be confused with guaranteed approval, an immediate payout or proof of the lowest-cost loan available.
Financial Inclusion Should Not Simply Be More Access to Instant Cash Loans
Another issue raised by Wonga is that consumers unable to access the regulated sector may turn to informal lenders who operate outside South Africa’s consumer protection framework.
This is a concern, but it does not mean that every consumer who is turned down by a regulated lender will turn to informal lending.
Consumers may postpone purchases, ask family for help or look for alternatives to taking on more debt.
An important question is whether increasing access to instant cash loans would improve the long-term financial welfare of consumers.
The 2026 draft National Consumer Financial Education Policy published by the National Treasury highlighted the level of household financial stress in South Africa. Drawing on NCR data, it reported that more than 10 million credit-active consumers had impaired credit records in mid-2025.
This shows why increasing access to instant cash loans must go hand in hand with affordability.
“Financial inclusion shouldn’t mean encouraging everyone to borrow more. It should mean making responsible financial products easier to understand and access, while giving consumers the information they need to avoid unsuitable or unnecessarily expensive credit.”
Finding the Right Balance for South African Consumers
The debate around short-term lending regulation will most likely not have a simple solution.
Wonga’s concerns about compliance costs, inflation and outdated regulated lending fees should be seriously considered. A system that makes responsible lending commercially impossible for some consumer groups may need to be re-evaluated.
Equally, consumer protection should not be measured only by the number of instant cash loans approved or the volume of credit extended.
Transparency, competition, affordability and loan comparison services should all be part of the discussion.
For McCullough, the focus should remain on the needs of the consumers seeking credit.
“A healthy lending market needs providers who can operate sustainably, but it also needs consumers who can make informed decisions. We shouldn’t just be asking how to make more loans available. We should be asking how to make sure South Africans can find the most suitable, competitively priced credit for their circumstances.”
The future of instant cash loans in South Africa should not be based only on what works for lenders or regulators.
It should be measured by whether consumers have fair access to responsible credit, genuine choice between lenders and a clear understanding of what borrowing will cost them.
